Liquid oral compositions comprising a calcium compound and an acidulant

ABSTRACT

Acidic oral compositions having reduced tooth erosion characteristics, especially acid beverages such as fruit juice drink concentrates, or oral healthcare products such as mouthwashes, are prepared by adding a calcium compound to the acid composition so that the mol ratio of calcium to acid ranges from 0.3 to 0.8, and the pH of the composition, if necessary after adjustment with an alkali, is from 3.5 to 4.5.

The present invention relates to compositions for oral use, such asacidic beverages and oral healthcare compositions, and to the use ofcalcium in such compositions to alleviate or prevent the tooth damageassociated with the consumption of acid. In particular, the presentinvention alleviates palatability problems associated with calciumaddition to beverages.

It is thought that erosion of teeth is caused inter alia by acidicfoodstuffs leaching out calcium from the teeth faster than it can bereplaced by normal remineralisation processes. When a product such as abeverage is prepared in accordance with this invention, and introducedinto the oral cavity for consumption or healthcare purposes, thedissolution or removal of calcium and phosphate from teeth by chemicalprocesses is significantly reduced.

Calcium is the most abundant mineral in the body. The vast majority ofcalcium is deposited in the bones and teeth but the mineral is alsoessential for other bodily functions such as the regulation of nervefunction, the contraction of muscles and clotting of blood. Calcium is acommon constituent of beverages being derived from fruit ingredients andfrom hard water when this is used in beverage production without priorsoftening. Values for the concentration of calcium occurring in this wayare typically in the range 0.005-0.02% w/w. Interest in the generalnutritional benefits of diet fortification by calcium ion has led to asearch for practical ways to incorporate this ion in beverages at higherlevels from 0.02% w/w to 2% w/w. The use of calcium as a supplement forbeverages has been described in W088/03762.

It is well known that the addition of malic acid will help maintain thesolubility of calcium in calcium fortified beverages thereforeminimizing losses due to precipitation. This is because of the formationof a soluble complex “calcium citrate malate”. On the other hand, Lussiet al (1995, Caries Res 29, 349-354) have associated the titratableacidity of a beverage with its erosive potential, the greater theconcentration of acid in the beverage the more damaging to teeth itbecame.

In PCT U.S. 91/07117 there is disclosed a method for preventing theerosion of tooth enamel by consuming an acid beverage (having a pH ofless than 5.5) comprising from 0.02% to 0.15% of calcium in the form ofa calcium citrate malate complex having a molar ratio of citrate tomalate of 1:0.5 to 1:4.5. In the calcium citrate malate complexes themolar ratio of total moles calcium:total moles citrate:total molesmalate may be from about 2:1:1 to about 6:3:4. A preferred complex forbeverages has the molar ratio 4:2:3.

We have found that inclusion of high levels of calcium in beveragesgives palatability problems. The present invention is based on thediscovers that effective reduction of tooth erosion in acidic oralcompositions can be achieved with lower amounts of calcium relative tothe acidulant when the pH of the composition is also controlled.

In one aspect, the present invention provides a liquid composition fororal use containing a calcium compound and an acidulant characterised inthat calcium is present in the range of 0.3 to 0.8 mol per mol of acidand that the amount of calcium and acidulant in the composition isselected so that the pH of the composition is from 3.5 to 4.5.

In another aspect, the present invention provides the use of calcium asa tooth erosion inhibitor in an acidic liquid composition for oral useby adding a calcium compound to the composition so that calcium ispresent in the range of 0.3 to 0.8 mol per mol of acid, the amount ofcalcium and acidulant in the composition being selected so that the pHof the composition is from 3.5 to 4.5.

In a further aspect, the present invention provides a method of reducingthe tooth erosion properties of an acidic oral composition whichcomprises adding a calcium compound to the acidic liquid oralcomposition so that calcium is present in the range of 0.3 to 0.8 molper mol of acid , and if necessary or desired adjusting the pH byaddition of an alkali so that the pH of the composition is from 3.5 to4.5.

In a still further aspect, the present invention provides a process forpreparing a composition of this invention which comprises adding acalcium compound to an acidic liquid oral composition so that calcium ispresent in the range of 0.3 to 0.8 mol per mol of acid, and if necessaryor desired adjusting the pH by addition of an alkali so that the pH ofthe composition is from 3.5 to 4.5.

The present invention is applicable to aqueous acidic substances fororal consumption such as acidic beverages, fruit juices, ciders, wines,vinegars and pickles and diverse acidic dairy products and also to otherliquid substances to be taken orally such as acidic mouth washes andmedicines.

Practice of the present invention does not cause taste defects inbeverages. Although the increase in pH of a beverage to around pH 4would be expected to reduce the sharpness in taste provided by theacidulant, surprisingly the inclusion of calcium in accordance with thisinvention mitigates this.

A further advantage arises from the use of low levels of calcium inaccordance with this invention in the form of an alkaline salt. Thebuffering capacity of the formulation is reduced by, partialneutralization of the acid, which allows saliva to neutralise residuesin the mouth more rapidly.

The absolute concentration of calcium used in the present invention isnot critical as this will vary according to the nature and concentrationof the acids present. The acid solution may contain organic and/orinorganic acids and may be supplemented with vitamins such as ascorbicacid. In a concentrated beverage, to be diluted with up to five parts ofwater prior to consumption, the calcium concentration may vary from0.001 mol. per liter to more than 0.05 mol. per liter. In a ready todrink beverage the calcium ion concentration may vary from 0.0002 mol.per liter to more than 0.01 mol. per liter.

The calcium may be added as any convenient salt such as calciumcarbonate, calcium hydroxide, calcium citrate, calcium malate, calciumlactate, calcium chloride, calcium glycerophosphate or calcium formateor any other salt to minimize any adverse flavour contribution to thecomposition.

The invention may be carried out by mixing the acid (e.g. citric acid)with its corresponding calcium salt (e.g. calcium citrate) or anothercalcium salt. It may be advantageous to mix the acid with an alkalinecalcium salt such as calcium carbonate or calcium hydroxide therebyminimizing the concentration of acid applied to the formulation. Theacid can also be mixed with inorganic calcium salts such as calciumchloride.

The molar ratio of calcium to acid may be 0.3-0.75, more typically0.3-0.65, preferably 0.3-0.55. Most preferably the molar ratio is atleast 0.4, and a value of about 0.5 has been found to be especiallyeffective.

The pH of the formulation may be adjusted to the desired range by theaddition of the calcium compound to the appropriate proportion relativeto the acid. If necessary, depending on the acid present, the pH may befurther adjusted by the application of an alkali e.g. sodium hydroxideor a suitable salt for example sodium citrate, sodium malate or sodiumlactate.

The pH of the composition is preferably not more than 4, most preferablyfrom 3.7 to 3.9. Compositions with a pH of about 3.8 have been found tobe especially effective.

Typical citric or malic acid concentration in a concentrated fruitbeverage would be in the range 0.1% w/w to 4% w/w. In a ready to drinkbeverage, acid concentrations are typically in the range 0.01% w/w to 1%w/w. Other potable acids conventional for beverages may also be used,such as lactic acid. Mixtures of potable acids may be used.

In a preferred embodiment, the acid composition is a drink concentrateprepared from a natural fruit juice, such as black currant juice, forexample a flavoured syrup concentrate. The calcium may be added in asuitable form either to the concentrate, especially when the beverage issold to the consumer as a concentrate for dilution before drinking, orwhen diluting the syrup concentrate for preparation of a “ready todrink” diluted concentrate. Preferably the product contains reducedlevels of sugar or carbohydrate or is of low calorie type containingintense sweeteners.

The oral composition may contain magnesium or other ions as adjuncts forremineralisation. It may also contain an effective amount of malic acidor potable salts thereof to maintain the solubility of the calcium so asto prevent or minimize the precipitation of insoluble calcium salts.Added malic acid may provide as little as 10% of the total acidity ofthe beverage, the remainder of the acidity being provided by otherpreferably naturally present, acids such as citric acid, or by ascorbicacid.

The invention may be applied in a variety of beverages such asconcentrates, still fruit drinks, or carbonated soft drinks and inparticular to health drinks such as black currant juice drinks orvitamin added beverages. The invention is advantageously applied todrinks containing natural or added citric acid. The beverages may beunsweetened or sweetened with sugar or intense sweeteners such assaccharine, aspartyl phenyl alanyl methyl ester, or other sweetenersknown in the art. The beverages may also contain other conventionaladditives such as sodium benzoate, sorbic acid, sodium metabisulfite,ascorbic acid, flavourings, colourings and carbon dioxide.

The beverages may be prepared by mixing the ingredients according toconventional methods. The solid ingredients may be dissolved in water orin hot water if required prior to addition to the other components.Typically drinks are pasteurised prior to filling in bottles or cans orother packs or arc “in-pack pasteurised” after filling. The invention isillustrated by the following Examples:

EXAMPLE 1

A concentrated beverage product, for dilution with five parts of waterprior to consumption was prepared by mixing the ingredients as follows.The calcium carbonate was added to the other ingredients as a finaladdition.

Blackcurrant juice concentrate SG 1.27 84 liter Aspartyl phenyl alanylmethyl ester* 1.15 Kg Acesulfame K 1.8 Kg Ascorbic acid 0.8 Kg Sodiumbenzoate 0.325 Kg Sodium metabisulfite 0.145 Kg Blackcurrant flavouring0.3 liter Water up to final volume 1000 liter Calcium carbonate 4.2 Kg*sold as Aspartame (RTM)

The mol ratio of calcium: acid is 0.5

The concentrate is adjusted to pH 3.7 with sodium hydroxide solution. Ondilution of the concentrate with five parts water (to drinkingstrength), the pH of the composition is typically found to be 3.85.

In-vitro planometry tests were performed in which flat dental enamelsections were exposed to test solutions at a temperature of 37° C. for30 minutes. Erosive potential was evaluated by physical measurement ofthe depth of enamel lost during the procedure. Whereas a controlformulation comprising 14 mM citric acid, pH 3.2 resulted in a loss of 4microns of enamel and a further control formulation of 14 mM citricacid, pH 3.85, removed 1.8 microns, a test formulation with adjusted pHand added calcium comprising 14 mM citric acid, 7 mM calcium, pH 3.85removed only 0.17 microns of enamel, demonstrating the utility of theinvention.

EXAMPLE 2

A ready to drink beverage was prepared by mixing ingredients as follows:

Ingredients % w/w Sugar 10 Sodium benzoate 0.01 Orange juice 5.04Ascorbic acid 0.03 Citric acid monohydrate 0.15 Flavouring 0.005Colouring 0.004 Water by difference 86 Calcium carbonate 0.048 Sodiumhydroxide   sufficient to adjust to pH 3.9 Carbon dioxide 0.48

In this beverage the mol ratio of calcium: acid is 0.46 (orange juice istypically 1% w/w citric acid)

EXAMPLE 3

A ready to drink beverage was prepared by mixing ingredients as follows:

Ingredients % w/w Sugar 8 Sodium benzoate 0.01 Apple juice 10 Ascorbicacid 0.03 Malic acid 0.15 Flavouring 0.005 Colouring 0.004 Water bydifference 82 Calcium carbonate 0.093 Sodium hydroxide   sufficient toadjust to pH 3.9.

In this beverage the mol ratio of calcium : acid is 0.74 (apple juice istypically 0.6% w/w malic acid)

EXAMPLE 4 In vivo Study

A beverage was produced by mixing ingredients as follows:

Blackcurrant concentrate 16.78 liters Aspartyl phenyl alanyl methylester 0.54 kg Acesulfame K 0.11 kg Ascorbic acid 0.45 kg Flavouring 0.55liters Calcium hydroxide 0.52 kg Water to 1000.00 liters

The calcium hydroxide was added as a slurry with a portion of the wateras a final addition and was sufficient to produce a beverage containingcalcium in a molar ratio of 0.5:1 calcium to citric acid. The resultantbeverage had a pH of 3.8. The batch was flash pasteurised and packedinto 250 ml “Tetra-Brik” containers.

In this study, loss of human enamel was compared between threebeverages: the above example, an orange juice as a positive control (pH3.8) and water as negative control.

Twelve volunteers participated in the study in a three-treatment Latinsquare crossover design. Each study period consisted of three weeks eachconsisting of five weekdays. In each study period, a section of enamelfrom an extracted healthy tooth was worn in an appliance for seven hourseach weekday. On four occasions during this period 250 ml of the testbeverage was sipped gradually, under supervision, during a period of tenminutes. The subjects were permitted to remove the appliance to consumea mid-day meal but were not allowed to consume foods or other beverageswhilst the appliance was in place. The enamel specimen underwentmeasurement by planometry (the principles of the method have beendescribed by Davis and Winter (1977) British Dental Journal 143,116-119) at the start of the treatment period and at the end of eachtreatment week. All readings were performed in duplicate. After awashout period, each subject then commenced the next treatment periodwith a fresh enamel specimen. The results are given in the followingtable and represent microns of enamel lost by the given treatment afterthe given exposure time and are the means found for the twelve subjects.

5 days 10 days 15 days water 0.098 0.153 0.166 blackcurrant 0.341 0.3760.407 orange juice 0.911 1.459 2.543

The results demonstrate that the black currant formulation was found tobe minimally erosive, barely more erosive than water, and highlysignificantly less erosive than orange juice.

EXAMPLE 5

In-vitro Study supplemented with either 0.0, 0.5, 1.5, 2.5, 5.0, 7.5 10or 15 mM calcium in the form of calcium hydroxide and the pH wasadjusted to 3.5 or 3.8 using 1.0 M sodium hydroxide. Samples of residualcitric acid were collected after every 5 min exposure of the teeth andthese were frozen at −4° C., prior to phosphorus analysis by the methodof Chen et al (1956) Analytical Chemistry, Vol.28, p1956-8.

The results are illustrated below

Mean amount Phosphorus calcium mol ratio liberated (μg) ± 1 SD (mM)calcium:acid pH 3.5 pH 3.8 0 0.00 1.41 ± 0.11 1.26 ± 0.17 0.5 0.03 1.25± 0.14 1.02 ± 0.09 1.5 0.10 1.07 ± 0.15 0.83 ± 0.12 2.5 0.17 1.22 ± 0.140.63 ± 0.13 5 0.35 0.79 ± 0.06 0.46 ± 0.13 7.5 0.52 0.72 ± 0.1  0.32 ±0.10 10 0.70 0.46 ± 0.13 0.24 ± 0.11 15 1.05  0.3 ± 0.10 0.14 ± 0.07

This experiment clearly illustrates that addition of calcium to a 0.3%citric acid solution reduces its erosive potential. The effect isgreatest up to a calcium to acid molar ratio of about 0.5 (approximately7.5 mM calcium). No justifiable decrease in erosive potential can beachieved by increasing the calcium: acid molar ratio much beyond thispoint.

EXAMPLE 6

A flavoured concentrate was prepared by mixing the following ingredientstogether with stirring. The calcium hydroxide was added last as a slurryin cold water and the volume adjusted to 1000 L with water.

Ingredient Unit Quantity Blackcurrant Concentrate L 67.1 Sweetener Kg3.33 Ascorbic Acid Kg 2.28 Preservatives Kg .0.45 Flavouring L 1.2Calcium Hydroxide kg 2.96 Water to 1000 liters

The beverage concentrate was flash pasteurised at 93° C. for 42 secondsand filled into 600ml bottles. The molar ratio of calcium to citric acidwas 0.4 and the final pH was 3.7.

On dilution with five parts water to drinking strength the pH of thecomposition was found to be 3.85 and the flavour of the drink wasdescribed as being typical fruity blackcurrant.

The beverage concentrate was tested for storage stability both atambient and at 30° C. After a period of 9 months no precipitation ofinsoluble calcium was observed.

EXAMPLE 7 In vivo Study

A beverage was produced by mixing ingredients as follows:

Blackcurrant concentrate 10.07 liters Aspartyl phenyl alanyl methylester 0.21 kg Acesulfame K 0.07 kg Ascorbic acid 0.27 kg Lactic acid 80%w/w 0.66 liters Potassium sorbate 0.1 kg Sodium metabisulfite 0.02 kgFlavouring 0.56 liters Calcium hydroxide 0.52 kg Water to 600.00 liters

The calcium hydroxide was added as a slurry with a portion of the wateras a final addition and was sufficient to produce a beverage containingcalcium in a molar ratio of 0.45:1 calcium to citric acid/lactic acid.The resultant beverage had a pH of 3.85. The batch was packed in 250mlcontainers and “in-pack” pasteurised.

In this study, loss of human enamel was compared between four beverages:the above example, a commercially available blackcurrant fruit drinkwith a pH of 3.0 and no added calcium an orange juice as a positivecontrol (pH 3.9) and water as negative control.

Twelve volunteers participated in the study. Each study period consistedof three weeks each consisting of five weekdays. In each study period, asection of enamel from an extracted healthy tooth was worn in anappliance for seven hours each weekday. On four occasions during thisperiod 250 ml of the test beverage was sipped gradually, undersupervision, during a period of ten minutes. The subjects were permittedto remove the appliance to consume a mid day meal but were not allowedto consume foods or other beverages whilst the appliance was in place.The enamel specimen undervent measurement by planometry (the principlesof the method have been described by Davis and Winter (1977) BritishDental Journal 143, 116-119) at the start of the treatment period and atthe end of each treatment week. All readings were performed induplicate. After a washout period, each subject then commenced the nexttreatment period with a fresh enamel specimen.

The results are given in the following table and represent microns ofenamel lost by the given treatment after the given exposure time.

15 days water 0.11 blackcurrant 0.39 commercial blackcurrant 1.44 orangejuice 1.29

The results demonstrate that the blackcurrant formulation was found tobe minimally erosive, barely more erosive than water, and highlysignificantly less erosive than orange juice or the commercialblackcurrant drink.

EXAMPLE 8

A cola concentrate was prepared by mixing the following ingredientstogether

orthophosphoric acid SG 1.585 41 l citric acid 120 Kg caffeine BP 5.3 Kgcola emulsion 29.25 l caramel double strength 125 l water to 400 l

A cola syrup with a throw of 1+5 was then prepared by mixing thefollowing ingredients together

Aspartyl phenyl alanyl methyl ester 1.8 Kg soluble saccharin 500 g colaconcentrate 25 l cola booster 600 mls calcium hydroxide 3.108 Kg waterto 1000 l

The calcium hydroxide was added as a slurry with a portion of the wateras a final addition and the cola syrup was then diluted with carbonatedwater, canned and in pack pasteurised to produce a finished product witha pH of 3.5 and a calcium to acid molar ratio of 0.6.

EXAMPLE 9

A mouthwash was prepared by mixing the following ingredients:

% W/W ethanol 96% BP 8 soluble Saccharin 0.06 cetylpyridinium chloride0.05 Tego Betain CK-KB5 0.2 flavouring 0.12 sodium acetate trihydrate0.05 acetic acid 80% 0.1575 calcium chloride dihydrate 0.123 deionisedwater 91.24

The ethanol, cetvipyridinium chloride. Tego Betain CK-KB5 (Trade Markfor a cocamido propyl betaine) and flavouring were mixed together toform a clear solution. In a separate container the remainder of theingredients were mixed together. The ethanolic solution was then addedto the aqueous solution to produce a mouthwash with a pH of 4.5 and acalcium to acid molar ratio of 0.4.

EXAMPLE 10

A ready to drink beverage was prepared by mixing ingredients as follows:

Ingredients % w/v Sodium benzoate 0.01 Malic acid 0.30 Flavouring 0.1Artificial sweetener 0.05 Water by difference 99.5 Calcium hydroxide0.083

The resultant pH of the composition is typically found to be 3.85 andhas a calcium to acid molar ratio of 0.5.

In vitro planometry tests were performed in which flat dental enamelsections were exposed to test solutions at a temperature of 37° C. for30 minutes. Erosive potential was evaluated by physical measurement ofthe depth of enamel lost during the procedure. Whereas a controlformulation lacking the addition of calcium hydroxide gave a pH of 2.5and resulted in a loss of 8.1 microns of enamel and a further controlformulation in which the pH of the beverage had been increased to pH3.85 with sodium hydroxide removed 1.65 microns, the compositiondetailed above removed only 0.6 microns of enamel, demonstrating itsutility in reducing tooth erosion.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method of reducing the tooth erosion propertiesof an acidic oral composition used for oral administration, comprisingadding calcium to the acidic liquid oral composition wherein the calciumis present in the range of 0.3 to 0.8 mol per mol of acid and the pH ofthe composition is from 3.5 to 4.5; and adjusting the pH, if necessaryor desired, by addition of an alkali such that the pH of the resultingcomposition is in the range of 3.5 to 4.5; subject to the proviso thatif the composition is a fruit-containing liquid having a fruit contentof 25 to 100% by weight and an acid content of at least 5 g/liter(calculated as tartaric acid), then it contains less than 2 g/liter ofdissolved calcium phosphate.
 2. A method of reducing the tooth erosionproperties of an acidic oral composition used for oral administration,comprising adding calcium to the acidic liquid oral composition whereinthe calcium is present in the range of 0.3 to 0.55 mol per mol of acidand the pH of the composition is from 3.5 to 4.5, and adjusting the pH,if necessary or desired, by addition of an alkali such that the pH ofthe resulting composition is in the range of 3.5 to 4.5.
 3. A method ofreducing tooth erosion in a human caused by acid in an orallyadministered composition which method comprises orally administering tosaid human a liquid composition comprising a calcium compound and anacidulant, wherein the calcium is present in the range 0.3 to 0.8 molper mol of acid and the pH of the composition is from 3.5 to 4.5;subject to the proviso that if the composition is a fruit-containingliquid having a fruit content of 25 to 100% by weight and an acidcontent of at least 5 g/liter (calculated as tartaric acid), then itcontains less than 2 g/liter of dissolved calcium phosphate.
 4. A methodof reducing tooth erosion in a human caused by acid in an orallyadministered composition which method comprises orally administering tosaid human a liquid composition comprising a calcium compound and anacidulant, wherein the calcium is present in the range 0.3 to 0.55 molper mol of acid and the pH of the composition is from 3.5 to 4.5.
 5. Themethod as claimed in claim 3 in which the calcium is present in anamount of at least 0.4 mol per mol of acid.
 6. The method as claimed inclaim 3 in which the pH of the composition is not more than
 4. 7. Themethod as claimed in claim 3 in which the pH of the composition is from3.7 to 3.9.
 8. The method as claimed in claim 3 in which the acidicliquid composition is a beverage.
 9. The method as claimed in claim 8 inwhich the beverage is a still fruit drink, a carbonated soft drink, or ahealth drink.
 10. The method as claimed in claim 3 in which the acidicliquid composition is a drink concentrate for the preparation of abeverage.
 11. The method as claimed in claim 3 in which the acid iscitric acid or malic acid or lactic acid or mixtures thereof.
 12. Themethod as claimed in claim 3 in which the calcium compound is calciumcarbonate, calcium hydroxide, calcium citrate, calcium malate, calciumlactate, calcium chloride, calcium glycerophosphate or calcium formate.13. The method as claimed in claim 1 in which the acid is citric acid ormalic acid or lactic acid or mixtures thereof.
 14. The method as claimedin claim 1 in which the calcium compound is calcium carbonate, calciumhydroxide, calcium citrate, calcium malate, calcium lactate, calciumchloride, calcium glycerophosphate or calcium formate.
 15. The method asclaimed in claim 2 in which the calcium is present in an amount of atleast 0.4 mol per mol of acid.
 16. The method as claimed in claim 2 inwhich the pH of the composition is not more than
 4. 17. The method asclaimed in claim 2 in which the pH of the composition is from 3.7 to3.9.
 18. The method as claimed in claim 2 in which the acidic liquidcomposition is a beverage.
 19. The method as claimed in claim 18 inwhich the beverage is a still fruit drink, a carbonated soft drink, or ahealth drink.
 20. The method as claimed in claim 2 in which the acidicliquid composition is a drink concentrate for the preparation of abeverage.
 21. The method as claimed in claim 2 in which the acid iscitric acid or malic acid or lactic acid or mixtures thereof.
 22. Themethod as claimed in claim 2 in which the calcium compound is calciumcarbonate, calcium hydroxide, calcium citrate, calcium malate, calciumlactate, calcium chloride, calcium glycerophosphate or calcium formate.23. The method as claimed in claim 4 in which the calcium is present inan amount of at least 0.4 mol per mol of acid.
 24. The method as claimedin claim 4 in which the pH of the composition is not more than
 4. 25.The method as claimed in claim 4 in which the pH of the composition isfrom 3.7 to 3.9.
 26. The method as claimed in claim 4 in which theacidic liquid composition is a beverage.
 27. The method as claimed inclaim 26 in which the beverage is a still fruit drink, a carbonated softdrink, or a health drink.
 28. The method as claimed in claim 4 in whichthe acidic liquid composition is a drink concentrate for the preparationof a beverage.
 29. The method as claimed in claim 4 in which the acid iscitric acid or malic acid or lactic acid or mixtures thereof.
 30. Themethod as claimed in claim 4 in which the calcium compound is calciumcarbonate, calcium hydroxide, calcium citrate, calcium malate, calciumlactate, calcium chloride, calcium glycerophosphate or calcium formate.31. The method as claimed in claim 1 in which the calcium is present inan amount of at least 0.4 mol per mol of acid.
 32. The method as claimedin claim 1 in which the pH of the composition is not more than
 4. 33.The method as claimed in claim 1 in which the pH of the composition isfrom 3.7 to 3.9.
 34. The method as claimed in claim 1 in which theacidic liquid composition is a beverage.
 35. The method as claimed inclaim 34 in which the beverage is a still fruit drink, a carbonated softdrink, or a health drink.
 36. The method as claimed in claim 1 in whichthe acidic liquid composition is a drink concentrate for the preparationof a beverage.